Mark Rein*Hagen's never-finished Exile (ancient RPGnet forum discussion here, its own page has long since fallen off the internet) was somewhat similar, starting with PCs sent to the frontier for crimes they may or may not have committed. The PCs were thrown out of a transhuman federation like Iain M. Banks' Culture, so the social dynamic would have been very different, and seemed less relatable than this.
Besides, I'm up for a setting that could eventually lead to Ned Kelly, Warlord Of Mars.
__________________ Buffy: The Watch House
Actual Play
"After her husband John has gone to sea and she loses her only child, Wat, San Diego resident Dolly Branican goes mad. When she recovers, 4 years later, she discovers that her husband's ship was lost at sea. As heir to a substantial fortune during her madness, Dolly uses these resources to finance the discovery of the whereabouts of her husband's ship, the Franklin because she doesn't believe he is dead. Years later a clue to the fate of the Franklin is discovered in Australia, Dolly quickly goes to there to discover that her husband may still be alive in a remote part of northwestern Australia. "
There are, it seems, two XIX century translations into English. At least one can be bought in a digital form, but you'll need to look for it since I couldn't find a translation at the Gutenberg Project. I Googled and found the next interesting links:
Thanks, Steve. I may end up trying to spin this idea as a miniseries with my group...this could be really great played as a grim-n-gritty funfest.
__________________
"[Y]ou WANT the car. The car is your goal. You do not want the goat. Either goat. Neither goat is better than the other, and they both suck compared to the car.." -- Matthew clarifies the Monty Hall Problem
"Waterboarding may make that guy talk, but it ain't gonna make him talk English." -- Jon Stewart, on The Daily Show
"RPGnet: Pretty Hunky Dory (For an Oppressive Regime of Fascist Terror)!." -- Nina tells it like it is..
I'm surprised the pitch didn't make any suggestions about using corruption among the officers as a plot device, since it was one of the dominant parts of politics in colonial Australia until the colonies managed to transition from purely penal settlements to being mixed economies. Plus since nobody outside Australia has ever heard of the New South Wales Corps or the Rum Rebellion, GMs can shamelessly rip 'em off without anyone being the wiser.