PDA

View Full Version : RPGnet Reviews

Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 [16] 17 18 19
  1. [RPG]: Supers Week - Legends Walk!: T&J Edition, reviewed by Mechante_Anemone (4/4)
  2. [RPG]: Tooniversal tour guide, reviewed by Tanner M (5/5)
  3. [RPG]: Circle of the Crone, reviewed by Temple (5/5)
  4. [RPG]: Vice Squad: Miami Nights, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/3)
  5. [RPG]: The Sewers of Redpoint, reviewed by NPC Jeremy (4/4)
  6. [Board/Tactical Game]: The Pillars of the Earth, reviewed by oni no won (5/4)
  7. [Board/Tactical Game]: Santy Anno, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  8. [Miniature]: Infinity: Yu Jing Starter Pack, reviewed by Thomas Riccardi (4/4)
  9. [Card Game]: Zero In, reviewed by Tom Vasel (2/1)
  10. [Board/Tactical Game]: Dart Wars, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/3)
  11. [Movie]: Fellowship of the Dice, reviewed by ShannonA (4/4)
  12. [Board/Tactical Game]: The Lord of the Rings Battlefields Expansion, reviewed by ShannonA (5/5)
  13. [RPG]: Fantasy Sagas: Player’s Guidebook, reviewed by area_51_games (3/4)
  14. [RPG]: The Fifth World Core Rulebook v.2, reviewed by Wil (2/2)
  15. [RPG]: Beast Hunters, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (5/3)
  16. [RPG]: In Harms Way, reviewed by Kester Pelagius (3/4)
  17. [RPG]: Champions World Wide, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/3)
  18. [RPG]: The Traitors Manual, reviewed by Travire (4/4)
  19. [RPG]: Scion: Hero, reviewed by Maijin Drew (4/3)
  20. [RPG]: Questers of the Middle Realms, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (3/3)
  21. [Board/Tactical Game]: Call to Arms (BattleLore Expansion), reviewed by Tom Vasel (5/5)
  22. [Board/Tactical Game]: Section X, reviewed by Tom Vasel (2/1)
  23. [Card Game]: Cineplexity, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/5)
  24. [Board/Tactical Game]: Fagin's Gang, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  25. [Card Game]: Trendsetters, reviewed by Tom Vasel (2/2)
  26. [Board/Tactical Game]: Colosseum, reviewed by ShannonA (5/4)
  27. [RPG]: Hush Hush, reviewed by The Unshaven (5/4)
  28. [RPG]: Legends Walk!: Truth & Justice Edition, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/4)
  29. [RPG]: ORX: Nasty, Brutish & Short, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (1/3)
  30. [RPG]: The Great Pendragon Campaign, reviewed by Bobo (5/4)
  31. [RPG]: UNTIL Superpowers Database II, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/4)
  32. [RPG]: Mage: The Ascension (revised), reviewed by pointyman2000 (5/4)
  33. [RPG]: G1: Steading of the Hill Giant Chief, reviewed by Lev Lafayette (2/3)
  34. [RPG]: To Go, reviewed by The Unshaven (4/5)
  35. [RPG]: Cold City, reviewed by Benedict (4/4)
  36. [Board/Tactical Game]: Colosseum, reviewed by Tom Vasel (5/5)
  37. [Board/Tactical Game]: 24/7 The Game, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/4)
  38. [Board/Tactical Game]: Numbers League: Adventures in Addiplication, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/3)
  39. [Card Game]: Cineplexity, reviewed by ShannonA (3/3)
  40. [Movie]: The Last Sentinel, reviewed by Kester Pelagius (1/3)
  41. [RPG]: Code: Black, reviewed by Sensei (4/5)
  42. [RPG]: Ruby, reviewed by Lev Lafayette (2/2)
  43. [RPG]: Lesser Shades of Evil, reviewed by Jocelyn Robitaille (5/4)
  44. [RPG]: Monsters and Other Childish Things, reviewed by The Unshaven (5/4)
  45. [RPG]: Hudson City: The Urban Abyss, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/5)
  46. [RPG]: Legend of the Five Rings, Third Edition, reviewed by Goblinhorde (4/4)
  47. [RPG]: Blood & Lust, reviewed by Jorgeman (3/3)
  48. [Board/Tactical Game]: Descent: Journey in the Dark, reviewed by Jamie Herbert (4/5)
  49. [Board/Tactical Game]: Fire & Axe, reviewed by Matt Drake (5/5)
  50. [Board/Tactical Game]: Fire & Axe, reviewed by Tom Vasel (5/3)
  51. [Board/Tactical Game]: Wicked Witches Way, reviewed by Matt Drake (5/4)
  52. [Card Game]: Clocktowers, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  53. [RPG]: Predators, reviewed by James Gillen (3/3)
  54. [RPG]: Bronze Gods, reviewed by Joe Sala (4/4)
  55. [RPG]: Artesia: Adventures In The Known World, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/4)
  56. [RPG]: Chaos in Carpathia, reviewed by privateer (4/4)
  57. [RPG]: Goods and Gear: The The Ultimate Adventurer's Guide, reviewed by Ante (4/5)
  58. [RPG]: Pirates of the Spanish Main, reviewed by MGibster (4/4)
  59. [RPG]: Truth & Justice, reviewed by Michael Erb (4/5)
  60. [RPG]: Cadwallon: The Free City Player's Handbook, reviewed by Michael Erb (4/3)
  61. [RPG]: The Ultimate Martial Artist, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/4)
  62. [RPG]: Nobles, Knights and Necromancers, reviewed by James Gillen (3/4)
  63. [RPG]: Paranoia: Little Red Book, reviewed by Neil Lennon (4/2)
  64. [RPG]: Saturnine Night, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/4)
  65. [RPG]: Magnum Opus, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/2)
  66. [Card Game]: Scum, reviewed by Tom Vasel (2/1)
  67. [Board/Tactical Game]: Rukshuk, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  68. [Board/Tactical Game]: Faces, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  69. [Board/Tactical Game]: Dungeon Twister: Forces of Darkness, reviewed by ShannonA (4/4)
  70. [Card Game]: Fishing for Terrorists, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  71. [Card Game]: Galactic Expanse: Starship Battles, reviewed by Tom Vasel (2/4)
  72. [Board/Tactical Game]: Monster Island, reviewed by Michael Erb (4/4)
  73. [Dice Game]: Wicked Witches Way, reviewed by ShannonA (5/4)
  74. [RPG]: Hero System Resource Kit, reviewed by ghost-angel (5/3)
  75. [RPG]: WWII: Operation Jedburgh, reviewed by mcrow (4/4)
  76. [RPG]: WWII: Operation Jedburgh, reviewed by ghost-angel (2/3)
  77. [RPG]: Spirit of the Century, reviewed by Michael Erb (5/5)
  78. [RPG]: REIGN, reviewed by The Unshaven (5/5)
  79. [RPG]: Masterminds and Madmen, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/3)
  80. [RPG]: Star Thugs, reviewed by The Unshaven (3/3)
  81. [RPG]: Delta Green (2007 Reprint), reviewed by NPC Jeremy (4/4)
  82. [RPG]: Earthdawn: Players Compenium, reviewed by Lev Lafayette (5/3)
  83. [Card Game]: Dragon Parade, reviewed by ShannonA (4/3)
  84. [Card Game]: Ka-Ching, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/4)
  85. [Card Game]: Apples to Apples: Bible Edition, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/4)
  86. [Miniature]: Armies of Arcana, reviewed by The Way and the Light (4/5)
  87. [Board/Tactical Game]: Anasazi, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  88. [\"Chose\" your own adventure]: You Can Be The Stainless Steel Rat, reviewed by migo (2/1)
  89. [RPG]: BUDO: Hard-style Wushu, reviewed by grandmaster_cain (3/3)
  90. [RPG]: Dark Champions, reviewed by ghost-angel (4/5)
  91. [RPG]: OSRIC - Old School Reference & Index Compendium, reviewed by migo (4/4)
  92. [RPG]: Super System 2nd Edition, reviewed by privateer (4/4)
  93. [Board/Tactical Game]: Proxima Obertura, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/1)
  94. [Card Game]: Treasure Fleet, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  95. [Card Game]: Nacho Loco, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/2)
  96. [Miniature]: Armies of Arcana, reviewed by Zinkala (3/5)
  97. [Card Game]: Unspeakable Words, reviewed by ShannonA (5/3)
  98. [Board/Tactical Game]: Battleground: Fantasy Warfare Scenario Book and Terrain Pack, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/5)
  99. [RPG]: Reality Storm, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/3)
  100. [RPG]: Scourge of the Howling Horde, reviewed by Joe Sala (3/1)
  101. [RPG]: BUDO - Hard Style Wushu, reviewed by Aaron Smith (4/4)
  102. [RPG]: Seven Leagues, reviewed by Lev Lafayette (4/3)
  103. [RPG]: Wicked Fantasy Factory #1: Rumble in the Wizard’s Tower, reviewed by Justin Georgi (4/4)
  104. [RPG]: B.A.S.H. Fantasy Edition, reviewed by Ace (4/5)
  105. [RPG]: The Manual of Exalted Power Lunars, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (5/5)
  106. [Board/Tactical Game]: Winds of Plunder, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/4)
  107. [Card Game]: Six Generations, reviewed by Tom Vasel (3/3)
  108. [Board/Tactical Game]: BattleLore: Goblins Skirmisher Specialist Pack, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/5)
  109. [Board/Tactical Game]: BattleLore: Dwarven Battalion Specialist Pack, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/4)
  110. [Board/Tactical Game]: BattleLore: Epic BattleLore, reviewed by Tom Vasel (4/4)
  111. [Board/Tactical Game]: Ubongo, reviewed by ShannonA (5/5)
  112. [RPG]: Books of Sorcery, Vol. 2: The White and Black Treatises, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/4)
  113. [RPG]: RuneQuest Player's Update, reviewed by Andrew Montgomery (4/4)
  114. [RPG]: Exalted 2nd Edition, reviewed by yoacusna (4/3)
  115. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Ruby, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (1/1)
  116. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week - Gamescapes: Story Cards, Sci-fi Set 1, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (3/3)
  117. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week - Gamescapes: Story Maps, Sci-fi Set 1, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/3)
  118. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Expendables, reviewed by mitchw (2/3)
  119. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Shock - Social Science Fiction, reviewed by azrianni (3/2)
  120. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: 2320AD, reviewed by Steffworthington (5/5)
  121. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Star Wars The Roleplaying Game - Saga Edition, reviewed by Andrew Montgomery (4/4)
  122. [Book/Fiction]: Sci-Fi Week: The Sky People, reviewed by Pilgrim (3/4)
  123. [Board/Tactical Game]: Sci-Fi Week: Saganami Island Tactical Simulator 2nd Edition, reviewed by Davyd Atwood (5/4)
  124. [Board/Tactical Game]: Sci-Fi Week: Babylon 5 - A Call to Arms Starter Set, reviewed by privateer (3/3)
  125. [Card Game]: Sci-Fi Week: EVE The Second Genesis Exiled Starter Decks, reviewed by Michael Remenak (4/5)
  126. [Board/Tactical Game]: Sci-Fi Week: Star Wars Miniatures - Starship Battles, reviewed by Jamie Herbert (5/2)
  127. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Shadow Falling, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/5)
  128. [Anime / DVD]: Sci-Fi Week: Gankutsuou - The Count of Monte Cristo, reviewed by Luiz Felipe Vasques (5/5)
  129. [Miniature]: [Sci-Fi Week] Transformers 3-d Battle Card Game, reviewed by Andrew Ellis Troubio (2/1)
  130. [Book/Fiction]: Sci-Fi Week: The Apocalypse Troll, reviewed by Eric Tolle (1/1)
  131. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Terran Empire, reviewed by ghost-angel (4/4)
  132. [Board/Tactical Game]: Sci-Fi Week: Babylon 5 - A Call to Arms, reviewed by Jamie Herbert (4/4)
  133. [Board/Tactical Game]: Sci-Fi Week: Federation Commander - Klingon Border, reviewed by Jamie Herbert (3/4)
  134. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Shock: Social Science Fiction, reviewed by edheil (4/4)
  135. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Horizon - Virtual, reviewed by Pilgrim (3/4)
  136. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Covenant, reviewed by Graham W (4/3)
  137. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Shock: Social Science Fiction, reviewed by Jono DiCarlo (2/5)
  138. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Inquisitor, reviewed by fsupadre (4/3)
  139. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Star Wars d20 - Saga Edition, reviewed by novastar (4/4)
  140. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Systems Failure RPG, reviewed by pookie (2/4)
  141. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Star Wars Roleplaying Game Saga Edition Revised Core Rulebook, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (3/4)
  142. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Burning Empires, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (5/5)
  143. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Serenity Role-Playing Game, reviewed by Luiz Felipe Vasques (5/4)
  144. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Universe (2nd edition), reviewed by Lev Lafayette (2/4)
  145. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Sufficiently Advanced - A Game of the Far Future, reviewed by Deadstop (4/5)
  146. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Fourth Millennium Campaign Model, reviewed by Pilgrim (3/4)
  147. [RPG]: Sci-Fi Week: Shock - Social Science Fiction, reviewed by Pilgrim (2/2)
  148. [RPG]: Sci-fi Week: Burning Empires, reviewed by Mechante_Anemone (4/2)
  149. [RPG]: Reign Supplement One, reviewed by Halfjack (4/5)
  150. [RPG]: Fury of Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (5/5)
  151. [RPG]: Island of the Forgotten Tomb: Swashbuckling Adventure and Campaign Setting for BASH! Fantasy., reviewed by Ace (4/4)
  152. [RPG]: Legends of Alyria, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (2/2)
  153. [RPG]: Harnmaster (1st ed), reviewed by Lev Lafayette (2/3)
  154. [Board/Tactical Game]: Conquest of the Fallen Lands, reviewed by Matt Drake (3/4)
  155. [Miniature]: Super System (2nd Ed) Summer 2007 Annual, reviewed by privateer (4/5)
  156. [Board/Tactical Game]: Epic BattleLore, reviewed by ShannonA (3/5)
  157. [Board/Tactical Game]: Descent: The Altar of Despair, reviewed by Beckett (4/5)
  158. [Television Show]: Kamen RIder Faiz/555, reviewed by Magnamammoth (5/4)
  159. [RPG]: Forge of Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (5/5)
  160. [RPG]: Hammer and Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (3/4)
  161. [RPG]: The Lost Isles 1: Exile, reviewed by Joe Sala (4/4)
  162. [RPG]: City of Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (3/3)
  163. [RPG]: Beast Hunters, reviewed by Graham W (4/2)
  164. [RPG]: Under the Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (4/5)
  165. [RPG]: Heart of Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (5/4)
  166. [RPG]: Spacer's Toolkit, reviewed by ghost-angel (4/4)
  167. [RPG]: AGON, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (5/5)
  168. [RPG]: Expedition to Undermountain, reviewed by J. Colin Madd (4/4)
  169. [Miniature]: Song of Blades and Heroes, reviewed by Sergio Laliscia (4/5)
  170. [Card Game]: Wings of War: Dawn of War, reviewed by TomVasel (4/4)
  171. [Book/Fiction]: Start of Darkness, reviewed by Joe_G_Kushner (4/5)
  172. [Card Game]: In Limbo, reviewed by ShannonA (4/3)
  173. [Board/Tactical Game]: Ingenious Travel Edition, reviewed by Joe_G_Kushner (4/5)
  174. [RPG]: Star and Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (3/4)
  175. [RPG]: The Ultimate Metamorph, reviewed by ghost-angel (4/4)
  176. [RPG]: Sorcery and Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (4/4)
  177. [RPG]: Metamorphosis Alpha, reviewed by rlotze (3/3)
  178. [RPG]: Player's Option: Skills & Powers, reviewed by migo (3/3)
  179. [RPG]: Reign, reviewed by Jocelyn Robitaille (5/5)
  180. [RPG]: Vampire: The Requiem, reviewed by James Gillen (4/3)
  181. [RPG]: Scion: Hero, reviewed by Shining Dragon (4/3)
  182. [RPG]: Brothers by Blood, reviewed by Dune Echo (4/3)
  183. [RPG]: Steel and Shadow, reviewed by arnonram (4/4)
  184. [RPG]: Monsternomicon Vol.II: The Iron Kingdoms And Beyond, reviewed by Wraithshadow (4/5)
  185. [Board/Tactical Game]: Fnap, reviewed by TomVasel (4/4)
  186. [Card Game]: Alpha Strike, reviewed by JonC (5/3)
  187. [Board/Tactical Game]: Age of Empires III, reviewed by ShannonA (5/5)
  188. [Board/Tactical Game]: Polarity, reviewed by TomVasel (4/3)
  189. [Card Game]: Whipped, reviewed by TomVasel (1/1)
  190. [Book/Fiction]: Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows, reviewed by Steve Fishman (5/5)
  191. [RPG]: Galactic Champions, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/3)
  192. [RPG]: Dread, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (3/3)
  193. [RPG]: Secrets of San Francisco, reviewed by Darren MacLennan (3/3)
  194. [RPG]: Aces & Eights: Shattered Frontier, reviewed by Galadrin (5/5)
  195. [RPG]: GURPS Lite, reviewed by migo (4/3)
  196. [RPG]: Passages, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (4/4)
  197. [RPG]: Hollow Earth Expedition, reviewed by mcrow (4/4)
  198. [RPG]: Mythweaver: The Splintered Realm, reviewed by Lev Lafayette (2/2)
  199. [RPG]: The Princess Game, reviewed by Jake Richmond (5/5)
  200. [Board/Tactical Game]: The Curse of the Ruby Rhino, reviewed by TomVasel (4/1)
  201. [Computer Game]: Battles of Prince of Persia, reviewed by Asklepios (2/3)
  202. [Book/Nonfiction]: Roleplaying with Kids, reviewed by merb101 (3/4)
  203. [Card Game]: Age of Discovery, reviewed by TomVasel (3/3)
  204. [Board/Tactical Game]: Cash 'n Guns, reviewed by ShannonA (5/5)
  205. [Book/Fiction]: Soon I Will Be Invincible: A Novel, reviewed by NiallNai (3/4)
  206. [Book/Nonfiction]: Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows, reviewed by TheodoreLerell (5/5)
  207. [RPG]: Tome of the Mysteries, reviewed by yoacusna (3/3)
  208. [RPG]: Kobold Quarterly Issue 1, reviewed by Joe_G_Kushner (3/4)
  209. [RPG]: The Chronicles of Ramlar, reviewed by DavidStallard (4/3)
  210. [RPG]: Legends of Excaliber True 20 PDF, reviewed by Treebore (5/5)
  211. [RPG]: Battlestar Galactica Quickstart Rules, reviewed by TrvShane (4/4)
  212. [RPG]: The Coming of Hanuman, reviewed by Benedict (2/3)
  213. [RPG]: Damnation City, reviewed by Willow (5/3)
  214. [RPG]: Miami Under Fire, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/4)
  215. [RPG]: Ravenloft: Realm of Terror, reviewed by migo (5/5)
  216. [RPG]: Lacuna Part I. The Creation of the Mystery and the Girl from Blue City, reviewed by Graham W (5/5)
  217. [RPG]: Fae Noir, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (2/2)
  218. [Board/Tactical Game]: Owner's Choice, reviewed by TomVasel (3/4)
  219. [Board/Tactical Game]: Tacklebox, reviewed by TomVasel (4/1)
  220. [Book/Nonfiction]: Achtung Schweinehund!, reviewed by Mikeythorn (4/4)
  221. [Book/Nonfiction]: The Elfish Gene, reviewed by Mikeythorn (3/2)
  222. [Card Game]: Jetsetters, reviewed by TomVasel (2/4)
  223. [Card Game]: Ruby Rush!, reviewed by TomVasel (3/3)
  224. [Card Game]: Toss Your Cookies, reviewed by TomVasel (5/3)
  225. [Board/Tactical Game]: Talisman, reviewed by ShannonA (4/3)
  226. [RPG]: Enchanted Items, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/4)
  227. [RPG]: Mythweaver: The Splintered Realm, reviewed by Wyvern (3/3)
  228. [RPG]: Don't Rest Your Head, reviewed by merb101 (5/5)
  229. [RPG]: Best Friends, reviewed by merb101 (4/4)
  230. [RPG]: Forward. . .to Adventure!, reviewed by pspahn (3/4)
  231. [RPG]: The Bestiary, reviewed by The Fiendish Dr. Samsara (3/4)
  232. [RPG]: The Hero System Bestiary, reviewed by ghost-angel (4/4)
  233. [RPG]: Black Sails Over Freeport, reviewed by talien (5/3)
  234. [RPG]: The Zorcerer of Zo, reviewed by Christopher V. Brady (4/5)
  235. [RPG]: Hollow Earth Expedition, reviewed by merb101 (5/4)
  236. [RPG]: Call of Cthulhu Sixth Edition, reviewed by merb101 (4/4)
  237. [Card Game]: Murdero, reviewed by Lynda Cowles (4/3)
  238. [Card Game]: Three of a Crime, reviewed by TomVasel (3/3)
  239. [Board/Tactical Game]: Age of Empires III, reviewed by TomVasel (4/5)
  240. [Board/Tactical Game]: BattleLore: Call to Arms, reviewed by ShannonA (3/5)
  241. [Board/Tactical Game]: The Fishermen of Catan, reviewed by ShannonA (3/5)
  242. [RPG]: The History of the Heortling Peoples, reviewed by Ian Cooper (4/4)
  243. [RPG]: Call of Cthulhu Quickstart Rules, reviewed by pookie (2/2)
  244. [RPG]: Mutants & Masterminds Beginner's Guide, reviewed by pookie (4/3)
  245. [RPG]: G4: The Vault of Larin Karr, reviewed by Joe Sala (4/5)
  246. [RPG]: Primetime Adventures, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (5/5)
  247. [RPG]: Wolves on the Rhine, reviewed by NPC Jeremy (5/3)
  248. [RPG]: Fantasy Hero Grimoire, reviewed by ghost-angel (3/4)
  249. [RPG]: Dungeonbattle Brooklyn, reviewed by pookie (3/3)
  250. [RPG]: High Medieval, reviewed by Dan Davenport (2/3)