Post originally by Roy Morgan at 2003-07-02 00:53:08
Converted from Phorums BB System

Having owned Witchcraft for some time now (the original edition and the Eden edition), I can say it's quite a good game. It's been criticized as being a little too close to White Wolf's Mage, but drawing from the same stories and legends isn't copying, and the game is different enough to be unique in its own right. The original suffers heavily from typos and editing mistakes, but the Eden edition cleaned those up considerably. It's amazing what a good writer can do, but it's more amazing how much better a good editor can make a good writer sound.