Post originally by Starchylde20 at 2003-08-27 18:26:27
Converted from Phorums BB System

Geez,

We're dealing with freedom of speech and my only comments were in the tone that I didn't find the same problems as the reviewer, and that I wouldn't have quoted chunks of the book that people could in turn use without buying the product.

My statements were personal opinion, and yes Alex did spend some time writing a review that I did entirely read. My statement wasn't to say that it was entirely bad. I thought my comments might cause a momentary reflection on some of the points I had taken time to write about and it's unfortunate that instead of taking these comments in stride of his reviewing abilities, him and others have come out to talk about how people shouldn't criticize a system that is designed to allow people to respond to the review being posted.

Maybe we should just take a breather and get on with something more important?