Post originally by Wes Johnson at 2003-10-06 10:23:27
Converted from Phorums BB System

A criticism from a guy who has yet to write a single review for rpg.net. You have the right to your opinion, but I reserve my right to refute it.

No good criticism. To use use your phrasology.

In retrospect I did write the review as more of an analysis of how it compared to prior versions of the game and other RM material through the years. My point was while it is a great setting (much more scholarly than the amaturish efforts of, say, Kingdoms of Kalamar). Which I did cover, why I thought that was not a great thing about this product, much of it is just repackaging of things that long time fans of it would already have. It is a good repackaging, but it is probably better for new people to the setting rather than long time people.

Ultimately I suggest people check out any book for themselves. Reviews are only a guideline, not a mandate.