Post originally by CK at 2004-06-06 15:13:49
Converted from Phorums BB System

>I must say that I find these technical >critiques of reviews rather tedious, but >as Aka-chan has shown, it's a free
>internet.

Well I was trying to be nice and supportive, I said it was an improvement. But okay, it's a free internet--These "tedious" critiques wouldn't be necessary if one does not make mistakes and say ridiculous things. When you review a product you say who it is by and who writes it. If that is a "tedious" critique, then why review at all?
It is NOT a bad thing to suggest someone INCLUDE THE AUTHORS. I know I would be insulted if I'm just left off reviews, but maybe that's just me. Now if the authors names were not on the inside cover, that's one thing, were they not? No one was listed?

Anyway, nor do I believe there was really reason enough given to buy this d20 version if you already had the other, which the review makes a claim that one should do. This is just my opinion of course.