Post originally by Buzz at 2004-08-31 08:00:57
Converted from Phorums BB System

<i>However, a mere (+1/4) notation doesn't make it clear that that’s what you’re doing – you’re not adding a quarter point to the point cost – you’re adding 25% of the original cost. Since the notation is not "standard math" it is impossible for those even with PhDs in mathematics to comprehend what exactly is meant by those fractions at first glance and, unable to comprehend the process by which the final number was derived, the new player is left to imagine daunting hoops through which one must jump to create a new character.</i>

Why does "first glance" matter? Sidekick explains what this notation means. How is it confusing if you've read the book? Aren't things like "HT 12" and "Ref +4" just as confusing at first glance? Heck, Sidekick even gives you a table that does all your Advantage and Limitations calculations for you.

I also don't know if I agree that GURPS is easier to tweak than Sidekick. I wonder if your extensive experience with GURPS has biased you a bit, Funky.

This was a pretty darn good review, otherwise. I think you're a bit harsh, and I don't agree with everything, but it's well-written and you explain basic concepts of the system quite well.