Post originally by Blue Seraph at 2005-03-01 14:12:13
Converted from Phorums BB System

The first quote should have been a complete sentence rather than a fragment. My apologies for the oversight:

"The very first impression I had was that James Earwicker hasn't played a roleplaying game published since around the early 1990's."

But that doesn't change anything. I didn't say the quotes were factual statements about the author; I said they seemed a bit personal. As contrasted with "professional." A better word would be gratuitous -- by the end of the two reviews, you were "twisting the knife" more than what was appropriate.