[Dark Sailor Mercury]

Originally Posted by ShannonA

There are 6 pages of pure rules errata. There are 10 pages of scenario related errata for the traitor. There are 10 pages of scenario related errata for the survivors. That's 26 pages total. I suppose when those were all one file, they might have been smaller, but claiming they're 4 pages is clearly an incorrect statement

I printed out the errata myself two weeks ago. 1 page for the Traitor's Tome. 1 page for The Survivor's Book. Some other number of basic rules related errata that was easily shrunk down to two pages and could have been shrunk more.

So yes, 4 pages is an incorrect statement. It could have been 3.

Originally Posted by ShannonA

Beyond that, you set up a pure strawman on the counters issue.

No, I'm replying to the only argument I've actually seen that wasn't a strict opinion based "They are poor" one. Granted, that argument actually wasn't presented in the thread and I didn't specify that.

Originally Posted by ShannonA

I mentioned that they suck because they're plain and ugly, mostly displaying texts. Your reply was, "Well, plastic figures would have cost too much." Would bits of art for the 250 pieces cost too much? Probably not.

Again, I wasn't replying to your statement at all and I apologize for not specifying that. You're just stating an opinion and really I can't argure with that. You found the pieces to be poor quality and I can see how someone could; I have no problem with the pieces and like them fine. There we go. And would bits of art for the 250+ pieces cost too much? I say probably.

Originally Posted by ShannonA

I'll stand by my conviction that the game was very poorly produced. Irrespective of whether the game is fun or not you're supporting that shoddy production, and asking for more of it, when you support this game.

Shannon

I see your opinion of the game is poor based almost completely off your dissatisfaction with the production and I can understand that point of view. I don't expect everyone to like the same games. But this idea that anyone who expresses a like of the game is encouraging crap quality on every game to come is ridiculous. It's strictly a matter of different opinions.