Quote:
Originally Posted by Travire
I'm puzzled by the negative response some people give to reviews.
|
Me too, Travire. I think your review does a good job of conveying a general overview of the system, but that more detail would have really helped it. This is especially the case since it's a Playtest Review, you could have included some instances from play where you just thought "Gosh, this *is* the greatest RPG ever." However, you do a good job of answering questions and elaborating on the game by responding to comments in the review thread, which really helps.
As to objectivity, some reviewers strive for a more balanced review while others just accept that this is their opinion on the game. Both methods are entirely valid, and posters can and will complain about "objectivity" no matter what a reviewer decides.