View Single Post
 
Old 12-27-2006, 11:09 AM
Dan Davenport's Avatar
Dan Davenport Dan Davenport is offline
Texas Moderanger
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 7,794
Re: [RPG]: The Edge of Midnight, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (3/2)

Great job, CWR!

I appreciate you including the Big Secret, as I'm always annoyed by reviews that keep them from potential GMs. (But then, I'm even <u>more</u> annoyed by <u>games</u> that keep the Big Secret from the GM. ) And I agree with Praetorian that the Big Secret in this case seems rather limiting.

<spoiler>Is the explanation for the White Event as understood by the characters in the setting something that people cooked up after the fact to explain it? And if so, who came up with it?</spoiler>

Speaking of spoilers, you might want to consider using spoiler text for Big Secrets.

Regarding the mechanics: since attributes are on a 1-8 scale and skills are on a 0-5 scale, doesn't the system strongly bias in favor of attributes? Or does the partial success issue balance that out?
__________________
RPG.net Moderator
Moderator comments in red.
Challenges to moderator calls should be posted in Trouble Tickets or mailed to Admin.rpgnet @gmail.com

dan.rpgnet@gmail.com
Forum Rules & Guidelines

Running: ---; Prepping: Earthdawn; Playing: Buffy; Reviewing: GODSEND Agenda; Reading: Earthdawn, Corporation
The hat of me know no limit!
"Did you know that your reviews take on an entirely new light, if you picture them as being read aloud by Frylock, as Meatwad listens intently?" - Cith, in #rpgnet
"You're more the lovable sort of odd. Like a retarded bear" - an IRL friend
Reply With Quote