[Chelemby]

I find BW to be both wonderful and frustrating. Luke & the gang obviously have put this together as a labour of love. The problem is that sometimes matters are not fully explained because they understand them so well. The core mechanics are simple, elegant, and full of unexpected variations. The way that Artha, Beliefs, Instincts, and character advancement all interlock is a wonder to behold. Combat, on the other hand, feels a bit strained -- it's an okay, but far from brilliant system.

I like the game; I want to love it, but can't quite go there. I think a 4/4 is a decent rating for BW.