Quote:
Originally Posted by Failed Saving Throw
As to whether or not this was a good review, look at the debate it triggered. I think my main point was to get people talking and thinking about the changes to come.
|
Ah. Then you and I are looking for completely different things in reviews. I like to be informed about a book and understand what the reviewers thought were its strengths and weaknesses. I like the reviewer to provide enough context that I can figure out whether I'm likely to like this book.
I am not interested in reviews that generate X number of pages of comments or provoke arguments about a game, especially one for which the core book has not been published yet.