View Single Post
 
Old 03-29-2008, 10:13 AM
C.W.Richeson's Avatar
C.W.Richeson C.W.Richeson is offline
RPG Reviewer
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Knoxville, Tennessee
Posts: 8,909
Re: [RPG]: [Actual Play Week] Qin: The Warring States, reviewed by C.W.Richeson (3/3)

Quote:
Originally Posted by charmed_rpg View Post
But Ebberon? you think Qin is 2 points less than that crapola ??!! lol
Howdy, charmed_rpg! Thanks for clarifying why you think <I>Qin</i> is exceptional, those sound like solid reasons to me! If you have some time you should consider writing a review. While we already have several, the more reviews we have the more ability folk have to decide if a game is right for them!

As to comparing different reviews in terms of scores, I'm not sure that always works out. However, I still happily stand by my recommendation of Eberron and would be happy to discuss why I find that product to be exceptional in another thread. I urge you, as I do everyone else, to focus more on the content of a review rather than the numerical score. Some of my favorite games I've given scores in the 3/3 range - a lower score doesn't mean a game isn't right for a particular person!
__________________
Latest Reviews: Martial Power, Diaspora, Chronica Feudalis, Monster Manual 2, Baby Names, Open Grave, Ultimate Toolbox, Manual of the Planes.
Next Review: Dragonomicon, Geist.
My Article on RPG reviewing for those considering taking it up!
LiveJournal
Reply With Quote