[Dagor]

I have to admit that after reading this, my immediate gut reaction was "Okay, nice forum article...but, dude, where's the review?" I re-read it to make sure I hadn't skipped over anything important, and the feeling persists.

If I was a first-time visitor to this site and chanced upon this 'review' as one of the first things I happened to read (which wouldn't be unlikely since as of this writing the link to it is right on the title page), it would tell me a fair bit about the author's personal disappointment with D&D 4th edition...but preciously little about what the game is actually like, even if I had experience with previous editions (not necessarily a given). Which to me seems to be kind of defeating the purpose of the whole exercise...