View Single Post
 
Old 06-24-2008, 10:24 PM
Evan Waters's Avatar
Evan Waters Evan Waters is offline
Talented Amateur
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Posts: 13,161
Re: [RPG]: [Fantasy Week] Dungeons and Dragons Fourth Edition, reviewed by Belisarius

Quote:
Originally Posted by Spectral Knight View Post
D&D, RPG or not, is a very combat-oriented RPG, and the latest edition is more miniatures-oriented than even 3.5 (even 3.5 had fewer plugs for those annoying D&D collectible minis). The focus is on combat, pure and simple. Roleplaying takes a back seat to that. If it didn't, there wouldn't only be 8 pages in the PHB, the book that really needs pages on the subject, devoted to the actual roleplaying of characters. You're still killing things and taking their stuff. For many groups, that's as far as the roleplaying goes.
Except that making decisions in character and having the effect of those decisions decided by a GM with the guidance of the rules is STILL roleplaying. Roleplaying doesn't just happen out of combat, it's combat and social interaction and trap solving and creating characters.

How many pages are needed for the roleplaying of characters? I don't recall entire chapters being given over to the subject in other games.
__________________
STAR WARRIORS- Space opera, CARTOON ACTION HOUR-style.

Club Parnassus- My official blog.
DC Draft: New Gods Starts here.
Marvel Draft: The Avengers Stats here.
Hybrid Draft: The Forever People Starts here.
Reply With Quote