Quote:
Originally Posted by Crothian
Luckily, books can be reviewed without being played. But most reviews do list if they were played or not. That makes it easy to read only the playtest ones if you so desire.  |
I think your review is fair and frank.
I don't share most of your opinions, but still, I value your unique point of view and your fine writing.
From what I understand, you are perfectly right. A book review is a just book review.
Your review aside, I used to believe that RPG.net was not "RPB.net" and that it has the advantages of providing an "insider's look" about games and design, more that about just the books.
I sincerely hope you write another review, after you've played a full campaign, to tell us about your experience, because that's why I come and read articles here every week. I crave for the passionate insider's look, good or bad.
Maybe it's just too soon to review that monster of a game (no pun).