Quote:
Originally Posted by capnzapp
A total score averaging less than 3 is decidedly pedestrian by rpg.net standards, and I must say the book is very nice indeed:
In short: Far worse entries have gotten scores in the 4's, and this one I would say is not deserving of any less! All in my opinion of course  |
I'm glad you like it, capnzapp! I'm not aware of any standard score assigned by RPGnet. If there is any standard for RPGnet it's that everything is a 5/5 and deserves huge amounts of hype until it's neatly placed on a bookshelf. My review scores have always been considered harsh in that I actually try to go by the guidelines and assign 3 as an average.
Quote:
|
And besides the index issue I haven't really found any glaring mistakes - that is sufficiently rare to warrant a higher score all by itself, I would say.
|
Most RPGs don't have glaring mistakes... What kind of games are you buying?
