View Single Post
 
Old 10-08-2008, 09:58 AM
Spectral Knight Spectral Knight is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 126
Re: [RPG]: Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition Player's Handbook, reviewed by Jesternario

Quote:
Originally Posted by Susanoo Orbatos View Post
Its entirely relevant. I am using an example of something else that points out how a Full fleshed and detailed world is not required for a game to be a roleplaying game. Is Gurps not a roleplaying game because it doesn't have a base world? is HERO? is BESM?
Point out where I said that D&D, any edition, is not a roleplaying game. Or GURPS, for that matter. I said it doesn't have a setting, and it doesn't. As such, the 'flavor' text is ultimately meaningless save for a little inspiration.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Susanoo Orbatos View Post
If you want to rule out anything that might be called a universal game..
You're assuming that I do. Don't.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Susanoo Orbatos View Post
I don't see how this fails to "give a reason to rp" vs a plethora of other systems, ESPECIALLY all previous versions of D&D.
Kindly stick with things that I actually said. If you want to deal with a previous poster, quote them.
Reply With Quote