I just read a 56,296 character review. 13,678 of those characters comprised a fake play test. A full 24.2% of the review is a fraud.
Seriously, though, this review could have been phenomenal if:
- It was more concise and thus slightly shorter.
- The degree of vitriol was turned down a bit and replaced with a more objective tone.
- It included a real play test with other people.
My scoring of the review is:
Style: 3
Substance: 4
To the others, an odd turn of phrase -- point -- is not an indicator of lack of comprehension.