Great job, delor! This is an excellent, comprehensive review.
Having played the game for the first time myself last week, I have to agree with all of your assessments.
I'd just add one other thing: players coming to the game with experience in the CoC RPG may be shocked at how relatively wimpy the monsters can be. Even an aged professor can single-handedly mop the floor with a Gug or a Shoggoth, for example.
And I had to laugh when the card result came up that had the Arkham police department sweeping the town clean of monsters. Yeeeah... somehow, I think avatars of Nyarlathotep are a bit beyond Arkham P.D.'s resources.
