I almost got soured on it before I even started. While I had a definite interest—especially in Planescape and Dark Sun—even as a little baby nerdlet, the first local game store I ever set foot in was a hostile environment.
But later, I got together a gaming group, which somewhat mitigated...
Considering Talislanta is about as eclectic as it gets, it would probably be more effective to inquire into the policies of a particular race or culture. I doubt there's any one particular way in which they'd all work.
I haven't in the past, but it doesn't seem like an entirely bad idea. (While I can see not wanting to clue in the resident munchkin, "keeping their characters a mystery," in my experience, tends to be shorthand for "doing something slick.")
Or, alternately: that's not a Boolean "and." :p
Back on topic, I could swear I found a few images that fit. But now, I can't recall where they were. So here's a steampunk orc. Whether or not she qualifies should be left up to the viewer's discretion. (I'd trust the artist with my three-eyed...
Aside from the fact that that's all subjective (or at least highly debatable)? Starting a post off with the presumption that the opposition doesn't "understand" never sets a good precedent. Disagreement does not equal incomprehension.
As of when I started typing that, it looked like there was still some debate as to who, exactly, it had been.
My argument was intended in good faith. Let's just have that out in the open, shall we?
And while my experience is admittedly limited, I really haven't seen that many of the latter...
Re: Double Poll - what version of D&D do you like best and when did you start playing
First D&D game I ever played was AD&D. I wasn't all that impressed—at least, not with the "crunch" of it.
Later, I picked up 3e. I liked it better.
Nowadays, it's Pathfinder. I really can't get into...
You know, you're right. While it was a flat denial, perhaps I read a bit more indignation into it than was there. I'm willing to admit as much.
The same can't be said of your later posts.
I am no more attempting to "paint myself as the aggrieved party" than is anyone else here.
It would explain it to some degree if the responses weren't invariably so extreme, regardless of circumstances.
It would be one thing if I'd been the one to actually broach the subject (which I was not), or if I had been using it as an insult. But I was neutral. And yet, not only was the...
And I made it abundantly clear that I didn't intend it as such. "LULZWURLDUVDUNJINCRAPHT" comments, and the prevalence thereof, are entirely beside the point.
Indeed. And if all that either of us can seem to produce here are anecdotes, I would suggest that we agree to disagree.
And yet, just about everyone I know who's played both would disagree with you, and call denying the similarity—and especially denying any similarity—"absurd." Sorry.
Hey, I wasn't the one who initially brought it up. I was simply the one who asked why it's automatically considered such an insult.
That would make two of us.
Let's first look at your terminology here: "at worst." This suggests that electronic-game inspiration is innately a bad thing. While I'm not impressed with 4e, video-game inspiration is not necessarily negative.
Secondly, if that's how it went? That's...