Ya, Hero. Or at least, fans of the Hero system would definitely say that it can do anything, so it certainly can do Exalted. There has to be some other appeal about Exalted (or WotG, for that matter) besides the raw powergaming element. If Exalted was done with Hero, with the same background, same artwork, same production qualities, and same power-gaming goodness, would it still be appealing?Power-gaming is fun. You get to kick ass mercilessly, you get to blow stuff up, and you get to leap through the air from tree to tree crossing swords with magical sword-wielding hot chicks. Does anything else even compare?
Now... to be forthright, I've never played any White Wolf Games, neither Exalted (though all the hubbub has made me consider making a purchase, just to see what it's all about). But I don't understand this statement at all.One of the best things about the new Exalted is the elimination of many opposed rolls. Opposed rolls are a poor way to deal with opposed conflict.
I think that not purchasing the new game would be almost criminal. The changes made are not minor, it is just that players of existing games are apt to ignore them.Lethe said:Good review, but I'd like to see a little bit more of a comparison content wise with Exalted first edition.
From what I've heard that are a few minor rules changes to charms, some emphasis on social combat, and that's about it.
It doesn't sound like there's anything in the new edition to warrant a purchase if you have first edition, except for you really dig the art (which I don't).
Powerless geeks spout off about a lot of things, who knows. As for the art, I think that sayingthis is the best looking RPG product ever is pretty high praise. It just isn't very wordy.morgonstjarnan said:I agree with most points of the column, except for a few issues.
The fact that there's a whole lot of setting material just crammed in there is great. He forgot to mention the amazing art in enough detail (two-three paragraphs of fanboyism might do). The lack of making fun of the Games of Divinity, the dumbest idea in gaming since the rules system of the Elfquest RPG. Oh, and yes. The politics.. why, oh why, do powerless geeks need to gush and spout political dogma? Why?
Reminds me a bit of Sebastian LaCroix's comments about how for every decision made there are legions thinking the decision was made as a result of a whimsical dart toss, and how their own ideas are better. Humor.