Aha! I will attack, then, once I get home and off my phone.
Sharpshooter, it is why I roll +5 to hit and not +10Ready is an action taken in combat. Since the party wasn't in combat, I should not have allowed Vorodos to ready a shot at the leader whenever he raised his sword.
EDIT: Why are your damage rolls +15 and not +5? What am I missing here?
I don't really care which one I target . . . let's say M6. If the AoO hits but doesn't drop the target he'll attack again, intending to knock out but not kill:Sury's AoO is from Round 1. Does he have an action for Round 2?
Also, which bandit did you target? M4 or M6? You would hit either one so assume one of them is still within reach.