Exile to the godforsaken reaches of the North
Okay, yeah, Elliot's not the most normal, but Ashley is used to his weirdness; the others might appear stranger at first glance.
It's different ways to be an outsider/insider. Magic is just one of them.Uh, Ashley isn't straight herself, so I don't think she'd consider a gay or bi person to be "abnormal". It really seems odd to even mention such mundane real world characteristics as sexual orientation or gender identity in the same list as blatantly magical superpowers.
I feel it's the only relevant one here, which would make Sam and Justin the most normal cast members. They have one supernatural thing about them, are mostly uninvolved with the rest of the weird goings-on, and are more important to the story than the truly mundane side characters like Tensaided.It's different ways to be an outsider/insider. Magic is just one of them.