I'll agree. This supplement is one of my all-time favorites. I kept a copy handy when I was working at Interplay and showed it off to new designers.Seems like the reviewer didn't understand the product very well, and likely never actually used it to help create an adventure, which was the entire point. Yes, there are forms, but they are to help you organize your notes and ideas. There are also a lot of random generation tables for plot points and what not, all of the "use them if you want to, ignore them if you don't" variety.