Will GM for Beer
Curse your sudden but inevitable food habit!Recruiter: I'm pretty open with who I take, and have only got really burned once, and really flaked off twice (if the player retires from the game with any sort of message I don't consider that a flake, just the cost of PbP). But at this point, my games have waiting lists, which helps as a filter... you have to really want to play, because it might be a while before you get in.
Recruitee:I'm very, very picky... I'd pretty much have to be point blank invited to join a game as a player. I'm just not that good of a player, and I'm not actually really interested in being a player. I'd be really, really happy if I could just run games for folks all the time. The need to eat and support others precludes this, unfortunately.
My biggest problem with connecting in PBP is it's rare I see games I actually play start up. I can't even think about getting picky before that.