Ramping up disapproval isn't bad. Go for it! I honestly haven't rolled disapproval range very often, and most of the time it's been a minor result, like praying to my god for 10 minutes after the fight's over. Failing can create interesting moments in the game just like succeeding does.My problem with the cleric has been that I'm afraid to cast any spells because I can't take the chance of ramping up disapproval and later needing to heal. It means I mostly melee attack and heal bot. Oh other than detect evil, which is farcically OP in a dungeon crawl and is constantly up.